Skip to content
OnTrial
GuidesInsurance defense

How to choose a sub rosa surveillance vendor for insurance defense

By the OnTrial investigations team ·

The short answer

The short answer

Choose a sub rosa vendor that is licensed where the claimant lives, observes only in public view, plans each deployment from a background and social-media workup instead of selling open-ended hours, and delivers timestamped video with an investigator's report and documented chain of custody. Ask how the vendor reports activity that supports the claimant, because a record that only shows one side is easy to attack. In Texas, verify the company's license number in the Texas DPS public license search before you assign the file.

The short version

  • Licensing comes first: confirm the company license, and ask who will actually be in the field.
  • Lawful methods only: public view, no trespass, no pretext contact, no provocation.
  • Intelligence before hours: a background and social workup tells operators which days and places matter.
  • Evidence that holds up: timestamped video, a written report, chain of custody and hashed files.
  • Schedule around the milestone: order before the IME, EUO, mediation or reserve decision, not after.

What sub rosa surveillance is for

Sub rosa surveillance is covert, lawful observation of a claimant to document their real-world activity against the restrictions they have claimed. In insurance defense it answers one narrow question: does what the claimant does match what the claimant says they cannot do?

It is most useful when the file already carries a reason to look: inconsistent statements, a recovery that runs longer than the injury suggests, social-media posts that don't fit the claim, or an upcoming independent medical examination (IME), examination under oath (EUO), mediation or reserve decision. Without a reason to look, surveillance turns into expensive hours of an empty driveway.

Licensing and who does the work

Surveillance is regulated investigative work. In Texas, investigations companies are licensed by the Department of Public Safety under Texas Occupations Code Chapter 1702, and the license number can be checked in the public TOPS license search. Other states have their own rules, so confirm the vendor is licensed where the claimant lives and works.

Ask who will actually be in the vehicle. Many vendors subcontract field work in some regions. That is common and not a problem in itself, but you should know it before the assignment, and the subcontractor should meet the same licensing and evidence standards.

Lawful methods protect the claim

Footage obtained the wrong way can damage the defense more than no footage at all. A vendor should observe only what is in public view, without trespass, without pretext contact or staged encounters, and without provoking the claimant into activity. Operators should break off rather than risk detection or confrontation.

Assume the footage and the investigator's report may be produced in discovery and examined in deposition. Defense counsel decides the strategy and timing of disclosure; the vendor's job is a record that survives that scrutiny.

Intelligence-led deployment beats hourly surveillance

The cost of sub rosa is mostly field hours, and most wasted hours come from deploying without a plan. Before operators go out, a good vendor builds a picture of the claimant: current addresses and vehicles, employment indications, public social-media activity, and routines that suggest when the claimant is likely to be active.

That workup tells the operators which days, times and places matter, so surveillance is scheduled where activity is likely instead of where it is merely possible. It also surfaces facts that may make field work unnecessary, such as a second job or a public post that already contradicts the claim.

What the deliverable should contain

Expect timestamped video and stills, a written investigator's report that describes what was observed and when, and a documented chain of custody from capture to delivery. Files should be preserved in their original form, ideally with a cryptographic hash so their integrity can be shown later.

The report should state facts, not conclusions about the claim. It should also record what the claimant was observed doing that is consistent with the claimed injury. A report that includes the supporting observations is more credible when it is challenged.

Timing: order before the milestone

Surveillance is most valuable when it lands before a decision point: ahead of an IME so the examiner can be asked about observed activity, ahead of an EUO so counsel can question with a documented basis, and ahead of mediation or a reserve change. Ordering after the decision usually means paying for evidence that arrives too late to use.

Questions to ask a sub rosa vendor

  1. 01What is your company license number, and in which state is it issued?
  2. 02Who will conduct the surveillance on this file — your employees or a subcontractor? Are they licensed?
  3. 03What background and social-media work do you do before deploying operators?
  4. 04How do you decide the days and times to deploy, and how do you control field hours?
  5. 05What are your rules on public view, pretext contact and break-off to avoid detection?
  6. 06What does the deliverable include: video, stills, written report, chain of custody, file hashes?
  7. 07How do you report observed activity that is consistent with the claimed injury?
  8. 08Can your investigator support the record at deposition or trial if needed?
  9. 09How is the engagement priced — fixed scope or open-ended hours?

Where OnTrial fits

OnTrial runs sub rosa surveillance for insurance carriers, SIU units, TPAs, self-insured employers and defense counsel. Deployment is intelligence-led: operators go out after a background, social media and geolocation workup, and every deliverable carries analyst verification, documented chain of custody and SHA-256 hashed evidence.

OnTrial, LLC is licensed by the Texas Department of Public Safety as a Private Investigations Company (#C31261501), with field coverage across Houston, Dallas–Fort Worth, Austin and San Antonio. Typical Texas matters include workers' compensation activity checks, nonsubscriber injury suits, and auto and premises liability claims. Engagements are fixed cost, with no subscription or monthly fees.

Where OnTrial isn't the right fit

  • Outside Texas, OnTrial's field work runs through vetted partners and contractors. If you need a vendor with its own employed operators in every state, ask about coverage before you assign the file.
  • OnTrial documents activity; it does not give medical opinions on what a claimant can or cannot do. That belongs to the IME physician and your experts.

Case study

The Inversion: pattern-of-life analysis on a disputed insurance claim →

Pattern-of-life analysis tested four sworn claims in a mid-six-figure liability case. Three were contradicted: the claimant's home and workplace were swapped. A surveillance plan was ready in five days.

Frequently asked questions

What should a sub rosa surveillance report include?
Timestamped video and stills, a written investigator's report describing what was observed and when, documented chain of custody, and the original files preserved with integrity hashes. It should state facts rather than conclusions and record observations consistent with the claimed injury as well as those that contradict it.
When should a carrier order sub rosa surveillance?
When the file gives a reason to look — inconsistent statements, a prolonged recovery, social-media signals — and before a decision point such as an IME, EUO, mediation or reserve change. Surveillance ordered after the decision usually arrives too late to use.
How do I check whether a Texas surveillance company is licensed?
Search the company's license number in the Texas DPS TOPS public license search. Texas investigations companies are licensed under Texas Occupations Code Chapter 1702. For OnTrial, search License #C31261501.
Why does a background workup matter before surveillance?
Field hours are the main cost of sub rosa. A workup on addresses, vehicles, employment indications, public social media and likely routines tells operators which days and places matter, so hours are spent where activity is likely. It sometimes finds facts that make surveillance unnecessary.

Related OnTrial services

This guide is general information for professionals, not legal advice. Rules vary by jurisdiction and change over time; confirm how they apply to a specific matter with counsel.

Put a licensed team on the matter.

Tell us about the matter and a member of the team will respond within one business day. No subscription, no monthly fees.